Judge Rules for Nickelback in ‘Rockstar’ Copyright Case


All of us simply wanna be large rock stars, and Nickelback will proceed to take action with out being any lighter within the pocket after a federal choose dominated of their favor in a copyright infringement case. The music that fell below query was the band’s 2006 hit single “Rockstar,” which Snowblind Revival musician Kirk Johnston had claimed mirrored a music he’d finished additionally referred to as “Rock Star.”

As Billboard experiences, the band emerged victorious after U.S. District Choose Robert Pitman dominated that there was zero proof that advised that Nickelback had ever even heard Johnston’s music and that after a evaluate of the lyrics, he discovered that Johnston’s accusations at some factors “borders on the absurd.”

One in all Johnston’s major arguments centered on the themes of their respective songs, however Pitman dominated that not solely did the songs not sound alike, however there wasn’t actually an overlap lyrically both.

“Acknowledged merely, they don’t sound alike,” the choose wrote in his order Thursday (March 16). “The place each songs evoke comparable themes, they’re rendered dissimilar by means of the vivid element of the unique expression in Nickelback’s lyrics.”

He continued, “This contains, for instance, any suggestion that the 2 baseball analogies in Nickelback’s work are proof that the band copied Johnston’s lyric ‘may purchase the Cowboys’ skilled soccer group just because each are ‘references to sports activities.'”

The choose provided that the one actual similarities had been broader cliches that had been “outlandish stereotypes and pictures related to being an enormous, well-known, rock star.” Additional exhibiting that such themes couldn’t be monopolized by one songwriter, he utilized a research of 17 different fashionable songs that shared comparable rock star themes, together with The Byrds’ “So You Need to Be a Rock and Roll Star” and Poison’s “Rockstar.”

READ MORE: 10 Nickelback Songs That Are Really Heavy

Nickelback’s “Rockstar” stays one of many band’s signature songs and largest hits. The music hit No. 4 at Mainstream Rock radio and crossed over to hit No. 6 on the Billboard Sizzling 100. It was featured on the group’s All of the Proper Causes album. which topped the Billboard 200 Album chart upon its launch. ZZ Prime’s Billy F. Gibbons lends some spoken phrase vocals to the monitor, whereas the video is full of celebs together with Gene Simmons, Child Rock, Wayne Gretzky, Ted Nugent, Chuck Liddell, Dale Earnhardt, Jr. and extra.

In his preliminary go well with from 2020, Johnston claimed that the Nickelback music had lifted “substantial parts” of his music, together with “tempo, music kind, melodic construction, harmonic construction and lyrical themes.” Within the choose’s ruling, he said that Johnston had failed to point out the place Nickelback would have had entry to the music. Johnston said that his band Snowblind Revival had carried out on the similar venue as Nickelback, however the choose claimed that was not sufficient proof to point out “entry.” “Johnston has offered no probative proof that defendants had an inexpensive alternative to listen to plaintiff’s work,” said the choose.

Nickelback might be touring this summer time in assist of their newest album, Get Rollin’. Dates begin in June in Quebec Metropolis, Quebec in Canada. You may get tickets to catch them dwell here.

Nickelback, “Rockstar”

35 Necessary Rock + Metallic Albums Turning 20 in 2023

20 years later and these rock and steel albums launched in 2003 nonetheless maintain up.

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here