Britney Spears Won’t Be Deposed in Lawsuit With Dad – Billboard

0
87


A Los Angeles decide sided with Britney Spears on Wednesday (July 27) and rejected her father’s demand that she sit for a deposition.

At a listening to Wednesday in Los Angeles Superior Court docket, Decide Brenda Penny finalized her earlier tentative decision to disclaim a request from attorneys for Jamie Spears to depose his daughter amid ongoing litigation over his alleged misconduct throughout her controversial 13-year authorized conservatorship.

Britney’s legal professional, Mathew Rosengart, argued there was no purpose for the pop star to face a deposition within the case, and referred to as it an act of revenge by her father and his legal professionals. “Whether or not he believes it or accepts it, what she went via beneath him [was traumatic]. What would an honest dad do? He would say, ‘That’s my daughter, I like my daughter,’” Rosengart mentioned through the listening to. “There may be nonetheless hope that he sits together with his counsel and talks about doing the appropriate factor. A deposition of Britney Spears would re-traumatize her.”

Jamie’s attorneys, in the meantime, have indicated they are going to seemingly enchantment, saying they’re entitled to extra data to defend their shopper. “As is the case with most of [Rosengart’s] arguments, it’s directed on the media and never on the court docket,” mentioned Alex Weingarten. “Mr. Spears did proper by his daughter. Mr. Spears protected her superbly from Rasputins and Svengalis for 13 years and the years earlier than [entering the conservatorship]. By proof, not speeches, the reality will come out. There isn’t any proof relating to Mr. Spears’ misconduct and he can be vindicated.”

To this, Rosengart objected, saying, “Mr. Spears’ popularity was ruined by himself lengthy earlier than my agency entered this. If he needs to go on TV or write a e book to vindicate himself, good luck.”

Although she dominated on Britney’s deposition, Decide Penny didn’t challenge a ruling on one other key query pending earlier than her: Whether or not executives on the pop star’s former administration agency, Tri Star Sports activities & Leisure Group, should sit for depositions and switch over extra paperwork to Britney’s authorized crew.

Rosengart, a former federal prosecutor, has vowed to research allegations of great wrongdoing by by Jamie, together with taking hundreds of thousands of {dollars} and illegally spying on Britney. Earlier this month, he received a ruling forcing Jamie himself to show over extra paperwork and sit for a deposition.

Rosengart says the Tri Star, Britney’s longtime enterprise managers, have key data for that probe – and doubtlessly participated in a number of the dangerous conduct — however has chosen “stonewall and obfuscate” moderately than cooperate.

In October, he subpoenaed Tri Star and execs Lou Taylor and Robin Greenhill, citing allegations made in a blockbuster New York Instances documentary that Greenhill and others at Tri Star had been concerned in creating an “intense surveillance equipment” to assist Jamie spy on Britney. That allegedly included “mirroring” the iCloud account used on her telephones, permitting them to watch her in actual time.

Rosengart additionally claims that Tri Star performed an integral position in creating the conservatorship in 2008, after which “profited handsomely” to the tune of $18 million. He’s pointed to emails during which Taylor allegedly mentioned how to decide on a decide that may oversee the conservatorship.

In November, Tri Star requested Decide Penny to reject Rosengart’s subpoenas, arguing it had already shared a “full set of its books and data” and had had no position in any of the alleged wrongdoing: “Tri Star performed no half in anyway in suggesting the institution of the conservatorship [and] nobody at Tri Star has ever instructed monitoring Ms. Spears’ digital communications.”

However at Wednesday’s listening to, after arguments from each side, Decide Penny left the problem undecided till a remaining ruling subsequent month. In a tentative ruling, she instructed that she would seemingly grant Rosengart’s subpoena, however would prohibit discovery to data pertaining to most up-to-date interval of the lengthy conservatorship.

In a press release following the listening to, Tri Star legal professional Scott Edelman mentioned the decide’s potential ruling could be precisely what the corporate wished.

“Decide Penny’s tentative ruling was clear – discovery goes to be restricted to occasions and costs related to the twelfth Accounting, simply as Tri Star had requested,” Edelman mentioned, referring to the ultimate interval of the conservatorship. “In brief, in the present day was an ideal day for Tri Star – no matter Ms. Spears’s counsel might have tried to spin on the courthouse steps. We stay up for being deposed, advancing this course of and guaranteeing that the complete reality is lastly shared.”





Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here